Sidebar
 
Character Search
 
SuperMegaMonkey's Marvel Comics Chronology
Obsessively putting our comics in chronological order since 1985.
  Secret: Click here to toggle sidebar

 Search issues only
Advanced Search

SuperMegaMonkey
Godzilla Timeline

The Rules
Q&As
Quality Rating
Acknowledgements
Recent Updates
What's Missing?
General Comments
Forum

Comments page

1993-11-01 00:03:30
Previous:
Cable #5
Up:
Main

1993 / Box 38 / EiC: Tom DeFalco

Next:
Die-Cut #1-4

Spider-Woman #1-4

Issue(s): Spider-Woman #1, Spider-Woman #2, Spider-Woman #3, Spider-Woman #4
Cover Date: Nov 93 - Feb 94
Title: "Deathweb, be not proud" / "You can't go home again (especially if you weren't really there the first time!)" / "Avenger on the Amazon" / "Tangled web"
Credits:
Roy Thomas & Dann Thomas - Writer
John Czop / Steve Ellis - Penciler
Fred Fredericks - Inker
Nel Yomtov - Editor

Review/plot:
I've always liked Julia Carpenter Spider-Woman because she appeared in Secret Wars and then later kind of mysteriously appeared as a member of Freedom Force. She had a cool design (the subconscious inspiration for the black Spider-Man costume) and was unusual in how aloof she seemed in those early appearances. Her mystique has been subsequently chipped away at as her origin and personality developed in various Danny Fingeroth-written fill-ins and then as a member of Roy Thomas' West Coast Avengers. The idea that her main concerns were juggling an ex-husband and a kid would never have occurred to me from those earlier appearances, and aside from that and a low key friendship with Darkhawk, i can't say that anything about her really stands out anymore. Not that she's been handled poorly, exactly, but she's just become a generic team member character. But i still like the character, and would have liked to see another take on her. So i opened issue #1 of this miniseries thinking to myself, "Please not Roy Thomas, please not Roy Thomas, please not Roy Thomas". But alas.

There isn't much of a story here. The main purpose of this miniseries is to make some nitpicky revisions to her origin:

1. Originally it was said that Spider-Woman was injected with a spider extract by accident while the government was trying to giver her super powers. It now turns out that she was injected by spider extract on purpose.
2. Spider-Woman's parents, who we meet in this story, are nature tour guides who work in the Amazon jungle, and they are the ones that provided the government with the rare spider that gave Spider-Woman her powers. They were unaware that their daughter was Spider-Woman until these issues, though.
3. The spider-themed villains Deathweb also got their powers via the same process as Spider-Woman, thanks to the arch-villain the Manipulator.

The plot of these issues is about the Manipulator and Deathweb going after Spider-Woman's parents (after killing the original project's scientist, Dr. Napier) so that they can get more spider extract and stabilize/improve Deathweb's powers.

Deathweb were originally created to go up against the entire West Coast Avengers team plus Spider-Man, so Spider-Woman by herself seems a bit out of their league. One member, Therak, is ionically powered and was able to more than hold his own against Wonder Man. I took a liking to Therak in his previous appearance due to his ionic powers. Spider-Woman handling him plus his two partners all by herself downgrades the characters significantly. Which may be why Deathweb as a group will never appear again, which is disappointing because they had potential. (Therak, thanks to the ionic connection, will get one more appearance.)

And since i'm harping on Therak being ionically powered, it doesn't really make sense that his origin is the same as Spider-Woman's. Another member of Deathweb, Antro, has basic teleporting capabilities. It's said that it's based on the capabilities of a trapdoor spider. That makes sense as a sort of retroactive justification for fitting yourself into a spider-themed group, but it doesn't make any sense if your origin is literally based on an extract of spider juice (Fun Science Fact: trapdoor spiders do not teleport). I've always been a proponent of the "x-factor" theory of super-powers (which says that a certain percentage of humans have the potential to become super-powered and the way their powers are triggered just determines the specifics), anyway, so it's not a big deal. But there was also no pressing reason to tie together Deathweb's origin with Spider-Woman's.

Anyway, beyond that the story is pretty standard. It's of course full of the usual Roy Thomas tics. As an example, in the previous telling of Spider-Woman's origin, Thomas thought it would be clever if the car that Spider-Woman lifts to prove that she has super-strength was a Daytona Spider. In this telling, he goes further with that, having Val Cooper asking Spider-Woman, "did you appreciate my little visual pun?". Like, yesssss, Roy, we get it.

I guess to my complaint that Deathweb should be too powerful for Spider-Woman alone, she does get beaten by them in her initial fight with the full team.

That's probably just standard "lose, then win" formula stuff, of course. But she has to be rescued by Mike Clemson.

We learn why Clemson has had a personal grudge against Spider-Woman and... it's really convoluted.

Meanwhile, the Manipulator uses the spider extract to increase Deathweb's powers.

But the Manipulator first used Spider-Woman as a guinea pig, so she also gets a boost.

It turns out that the Manipulator got his notes from Dr. Napier, who deliberately recorded false data to stop the Manipulator from getting what he really wanted. So Deathweb wind up passing out. The key apparently was taking a rest before trying to use your powers, and Spider-Woman did have time to rest, so she's ok. Manipulator is killed by Therak before he passes out.

The final panel is very weird. Manipulator had Spider-Woman's daughter, Rachel, as a hostage. After Therak kills the Manipulator, there's a panel of Spider-Woman freeing Rachel, and then two panels of Spider-Woman talking to Rachel, and then Spider-Woman yelling at two oddly specific-looking security guards (?) who had never appeared in the story before.

I don't know if Spider-Woman's power boost "sticks", but there are also a few other developments regarding her powers. The story starts off with Spider-Woman, fighting some generic crooks with USAgent. She tries out a new little power trick

She uses another power stunt against Therak.

John Czop's art starts off pretty decent, kind of like David Ross on a good day, which helps with consistency between this book and Avengers West Coast. On the later two issues, Steve Ellis is the artist. I didn't realize that the artist had changed and just thought that Czop got into deadline trouble and got sloppy. But considering (as Ben notes in the comments) that this is very early stuff for Ellis, the "sloppiness" is understandable.

Quality Rating: C

Historical Significance Rating: 1

Chronological Placement Considerations: The death of Mockingbird is mentioned, but Spider-Woman is still a member of the West Coast Avengers, so there's a relatively narrow range where this series can occur, in between Avengers West Coast #100 and the break-up/rebranding of the team in Avengers West Coast #102 (a footnote in #3 confirms that it takes place before #102). It can fit anywhere in that range, though. War Machine is said to be on duty at the Whacko compound when she borrows a Quinjet, so he's listed as a Character Appearing. Spider-Woman gets the details of her revised origin from Val Cooper (who is nearly unrecognizable thanks to miscolored hair and bad writing, but she's identified).

References:

  • Observing that USAgent is acting unusually nice, Spider-Woman says that he might be revaluating things after the death of Mockingbird in Avengers West Coast #100.
  • Deathweb previously appeared in Avengers West Coast #84-86 and that's where we learned Spider-Woman's origin.
  • Spider-Woman first appeared in Secret Wars.
  • She next appeared with Freedom Force, starting in Uncanny X-Men #206.
  • She broke off from Freedom Force when she freed the Avengers from the Vault in Avengers annual #15.
  • She continued to work for the government, with Mike Clemson as her handler, as seen in Iron Man #214.

Crossover: N/A

Continuity Insert? N

My Reprint: N/A

Inbound References (1): show

  • Marvel Comics Presents #166-168 (Spider-Woman)

Characters Appearing: Antro, Arachne (Deathweb), Consuela, Elizabeth Cornwall, Manipulator III, Mike Clemson, Rachel Carpenter, Spider-Woman (Julia Carpenter), Therak, USAgent, Valerie Cooper, Walter Cornwall, War Machine

Previous:
Cable #5
Up:
Main

1993 / Box 38 / EiC: Tom DeFalco

Next:
Die-Cut #1-4

Comments

I think the whole point of Spider-Woman yelling at the guards is that they had not appeared before. "What kept you?" as in "Where have you been during the whole thing?" though I guess the idea was for them to be cops arriving to the place, not guards who would be supposed to have been there all along, but were miscolored.
I think my favourite version of the "cops arrive after the fight" is a running gag in the Spider-Man Unlimited issue where Ben Reilly and Luke Cage face the Scorpion.

Posted by: DAMartin | March 7, 2017 5:44 PM

I picked up a back issue of this a year ago just out of curiosity. Roy Thomas's writing of course didnt inspire me to pick up more.

The only comment I'll note is that Julia Carpenter is fairly unique in the world of super hero parents in that they are both still alive. Not many heroes can claim that.

Posted by: kveto | March 7, 2017 5:46 PM

Issues #3 and #4 are actually penciled by Steve Ellis. It's some of his earliest published work.

Posted by: Ben Herman | March 8, 2017 10:03 PM

Oops, thanks Ben.

Posted by: fnord12 | March 9, 2017 7:23 AM

fnord, the inking by Fred Fredericks is pretty heavy, so it's sorta easy to miss the switch-over from John Czop to Steve Ellis on pencils.

Agreed with DAMartin that those two "security guards" must be late-arriving police officers who were miscolored.

Posted by: Ben Herman | March 9, 2017 10:39 AM




Post a comment

(Required & displayed)
(Required but not displayed)
(Not required)

Note: Please report typos and other obvious mistakes in the forum. Not here! :-)



Comments are now closed.

UPC Spider-Man
SuperMegaMonkey home | Comics Chronology home